Show se konala 1. května 2016 v Allstate Arena (Rosemont, Illinois). Jedná se o čtvrtý ročník akce Payback. Na této show se sešlo osm zápasů.
Réžia: Kevin Dunn
Hrajú: Joe Anoa'i, Allen Jones, Ashley Fliehr, Natalie Neidhart, Ric Flair, Rami Sebei, Kevin Steen, Mike "The Miz" Mizanin, Maryse Ouellet Mizanin, Claudio Castagnoli, Jonathan Good, Chris Jericho, Eric Arndt, Bill Morrissey, Matt Rehwoldt, John Smith, Ettore Ewen, Kofi Sarkodie-Mensah, Austin Watson, Emanuel Rodriguez, Ryan Reeves, Tom Pestock, Nick Nemeth, Jonathan Solofa Fatu, Joshua Samuel Fatu, Michael Coulthard, Bryan J. Kelly, John Layfield, Jerry Lawler, Renee Paquette, Lilián García, Vince McMahon, Shane McMahon, Stephanie McMahon, Chad Allegra, Andrew Hankinson, Bret Hart, Matt Polinsky